Spots the Space Marine: Defense of the Fiddler PDF »

Spots the Space Marine: Defense of the Fiddler ✯ [BOOKS] ⚣ Spots the Space Marine: Defense of the Fiddler By M.C.A. Hogarth ✼ – Buyprobolan50.co.uk Pollyanna meets Starship Troopers in this fast, screenplay like novel about a something Marine private called out of retirement to join the war against the crabs But shattered morale is the least of Pollyanna meets Starship Troopers in this fast, Space Marine: Kindle Ø screenplay like novel about asomething Marine private called out of retirement to join the war against the crabs But shattered morale is the least of her company s problems, and their survival may hinge on an unlikely friendship forged between an alien weapons designer and a mother turned warrior.


10 thoughts on “Spots the Space Marine: Defense of the Fiddler

  1. Christopher Christopher says:

    Before I tell you why I think you should read it, and why, if you do, I believe you will enjoy it, I want to tell you what s going to discourage you from doing so.When I settle down to read fiction I go into it mostly blind, but with a few expectations One is that the narrative will be told as a narrative, with some kind of cohesive voice, either in impartial third person or aintimate first person That is not the case with Spots Spots reads like a very spare movie script, with minimal n Before I tell you why I think you should read it, and why, if you do, I believe you will enjoy it, I want to tell you what s going to discourage you from doing so.When I settle down to read fiction I go into it mostly blind, but with a few expectations One is that the narrative will be told as a narrative, with some kind of cohesive voice, either in impartial third person or aintimate first person That is not the case with Spots Spots reads like a very spare movie script, with minimal narration and dialog relayed in script format The first time I tried to read the book I wound up putting it down, because it wasn t what I was expected I expected third person I expecteddescription I expected something that felt like a book instead of a movie script It made me rather uncomfortable, because I wanted the narrator to tell me what everyone was doing all the time, damn it all, and the narrator wasn t There are italics that mention when Claws was checking Spots armor, and scene and setting changes are identified, but not much else There are even sequences that are specifically described as montages.So I wandered away from the book for a while, because it wasn t what I was expecting to read, and that put me off It s entirely possible that you ll have the same reaction I did You ll look at it, and you ll be uncomfortable, and that will put you off.If you have that reaction, keep reading If you give the format a chance, you ll find it has surprising strengths in telling this story, and Hogarth exploits those strengths well Spots her squad nickname, call sign name, whatever you want to call it is a marine reservist who is taken off her one day a month desk duty and thrown into combat He s in her 30s, she s a mother of two, she s at least a decade older than everyone else around her, and she s posted to a place that s supposed to be relatively unimportant a place that s certainly not on the front lines but that seems to be gettingthan its fair share of enemy action.There are a lot of layers in this story There s Spots trying to fit in to her unit, and her unit not sure they want her to fit in There s the alien ally engineer Samuel Colt it makes sense in context who develops a rapport with her because of who she is in context with how his society works There s the backlash from the other marines because she s developed a rapport with an alien There s the war itself, and the mystery surrounding why the enemy is paying so much attention to a place that it shouldn t There s exhaustion no one has enough sleep, enough resources, or enough trust, and everyone is beginning to fray And there are politics politics between squads, politics between officers though not in the classically backstabbing way and politics between the enlisted and the officers.And there s a running theme throughout the story of what it s like to be an alien in your environment, to not fit into it, and not quite know how to adapt or grow into it M.C.A Hogarth is extraordinarily good at creating alien civilizations and making them feel legitimate, and her depiction of Samuel Colt and his race is fascinating You wind up makingconclusions about how he works, and how his civilization works, than the story actually tells you there are enough clues in there to figure it out And his interaction with the humans, and the enemies interaction with the humans, are wonderful puzzles in the grand tradition of inscrutable aliens But the truth is, almost all of the important characters in the story are aliens in their own environment Spots is old her squad members call her mama and nobody believes she s going to be much use in a fight One of her teammates is trying to convince everyone he s much stupider than he is The Lieutenant in command of the station is trying to manage their situation with not enough people or supplies She was essentially field promoted because the former commander of the station died leading an action that was monumentally stupid and that got a lot of people killed The fact that a lot of people were killed has ripped holes in the people who survived How everyone deals with feeling that way the ways they are unfair, the ways they are noble, and the ways they are just plain desperate are good reading.As all of these layers pile on top of each other, and as the mysteries surrounding the alien allies and the alien enemy deepen, you stop noticing the script format and you start hearing the dialog You hear the marines as they swear at each other constantly madenoticeable because you don t actually see what they re saying any serious swearing is censored with asterisks , you hear the marines say considerably less to their superior officers both in volume and substance you even hear the alien begin to joke with the few humans he s become friendly with I found that, after a while, the presentation of the story fit perfectly There s just enough narration to give you a feel for the chaos going around, but the true feel of that chaos is reflected in the way people are shouting at each other, or whispering to each other, or joking with each other in their down time It took time to slide into it, but once I did it worked, and I had to finish the book in one sitting


  2. Rindis Rindis says:

    Well, this is different and yet familiar The broad action and wider themes of Defense of the Fiddler are fairly familiar Military SF However, this is done in a script format.Beyond the oddness of that choice in general, there s odd things inside of this book in how it s handled The prologue and and one transition section are in comic format, so I assume that Hogarth was originally thinking of doing a graphic novel, but realized it d take too much time out of her other writing projects So Well, this is different and yet familiar The broad action and wider themes of Defense of the Fiddler are fairly familiar Military SF However, this is done in a script format.Beyond the oddness of that choice in general, there s odd things inside of this book in how it s handled The prologue and and one transition section are in comic format, so I assume that Hogarth was originally thinking of doing a graphic novel, but realized it d take too much time out of her other writing projects So we have a script that looks a bit like a Shakespearian play scene setting and descriptions are fairly minimal There s some notable ones at the beginning, which quickly drops to nonexistent, and then as the book goes on, the descriptions slowly fill out a bit again, and for the climax there s lots of descriptions of camera angles and pans, and yeah, this iscinematic than comics can easily do So you get an initial few pages of visual reference, and then you re left on your own to fill in the conversations with appropriate visuals Once you ve gotten through the beginning and have established the scene for yourself, thendetails slowly start filtering in keep you on track.It s an interesting technique, but there are some important details not expressed until well into the book The action is largely in claustrophobic tunnels, with the enemy crabs breaking through the walls as well as using the existing tunnels What isn t said is that this is all on a planet with a toxic atmosphere, so everyone s down below for their own safety It s obvious that something like this must be true, but the exact reason isn t mentioned until late, making it hard to figure out what these tunnels are part of.The story itself is multilayered, and very effective It takes its time to get going, but the cast of characters is surprisingly large, partly because they re introduced to you at a very deliberate pace, and you get to know everyone currently involved before expanding the scope slightly to introduce a coupleIt s a difficult trick, one that all too many books flub at one point or another, and it s masterfully handled here The script format take a bit of getting used to, but you are well rewarded for going with it


  3. Christopher Gerrib Christopher Gerrib says:

    I have been reviewing the work of M C A Hogarth since I reviewed The Worth of a Shell back in 2009 Full disclosure I was not the target audience for that book So, when word came of Ms Hogarth s run in with Games Workshop over an attempt to trademark space marines I decided to purchase the ebook version of Spots the Space Marine I can report that I am the target audience for that book, and that I enjoyed it immensely.Written in the form of a screenplay, and originally serialized on t I have been reviewing the work of M C A Hogarth since I reviewed The Worth of a Shell back in 2009 Full disclosure I was not the target audience for that book So, when word came of Ms Hogarth s run in with Games Workshop over an attempt to trademark space marines I decided to purchase the ebook version of Spots the Space Marine I can report that I am the target audience for that book, and that I enjoyed it immensely.Written in the form of a screenplay, and originally serialized on the author s website, Spots is the story of Magda Heloise Guitart, a thirty something woman who is called back into military service from the reserves She s shipped out to a backwater world, part of a detail guarding a Naval supply depot Perhaps needless to say, problems ensue nearly immediately Spots the marines all use call signs is significantly older andmature than her fellow Marines, and headquarters was in error when they thought her area was a backwater.The Fiddler they are defending is an alien named Samuel Colt, who is a member of the race that gave humanity the technology they need to fight this war Spots befriends Colt, while dealing with hostile aliens and becoming a valued member of her team The book is in short classic space opera, and a real romp.I should be clear though what it s not Despite the title, the book is not at all light hearted It s serious, and there s not a whiff of Boy s Own Adventure to be had The screenplay format does create a certain urgency when you re reading it, which works out well for this material There s one other idiosyncrasy to note Hogarth stars out all the soldier s curse words Presumably this is to avoid offending Spot s maternal ears It works but it s weird.And I think it works but it s weird summarizes the entire book It s not something that would be seen as commercial but it s highly enjoyable, and highlights what can be done with self publishing Recommended


  4. J.L. Dobias J.L. Dobias says:

    Spots the Space Marine by M.C.A Hogarth Is a delicious science fiction tale Written in a somewhat play or screen play style that can put off many an average reader For those who can tough it through, its beyond well worth reading Though the story is told mostly through dialogue M.C.A has a way of crafting her characters through that dialogue It s a bitwork for the reader and seemed to slow my usual pace down quite a bit, but it s worth the effort.I would not have looked at this book h Spots the Space Marine by M.C.A Hogarth Is a delicious science fiction tale Written in a somewhat play or screen play style that can put off many an average reader For those who can tough it through, its beyond well worth reading Though the story is told mostly through dialogue M.C.A has a way of crafting her characters through that dialogue It s a bitwork for the reader and seemed to slow my usual pace down quite a bit, but it s worth the effort.I would not have looked at this book had there not been controversy about it It seems the use of Space Marines is being sanctioned by another party.I find it hard to believe when I see the following information show up has an interesting chart showing the dates and types of usage of space marines dating as far back as 1932 Misfit by Robert A Heinlein 1939 uses term Space Marines Lensman series by E E Smith s 1938 1940 uses term Space Marines Captain Brink of the Space Marines by Bob Olsen 1936 amazing storiesWaitabits by E.F.Russel in astonishing sf 1955 uses term Space Marines Space Marines Space Opera RPG by A Mark Ratner 1980 In movies as early as 1973 use term Space Marines In games as early as 1977 use term Space Marines The United States Space Marine Corps by Eugene R Hudson 2011This book is not a game or not about games nor related to said game and even if said game has an armload of novels at a certain bookseller, that still shouldn t give them the right to contest two words that show up in a cover that hasthan those two words.That much said Spots aka Magda Guitart is the seemingly unlikely hero of the story As it unfolds we find that she s a wife and mother who has been at a desk job for a number of years When she s deployed into a conflict zone, this doesn t sound good or hold well with her unit members and just about all except for Claws aka Travis Walker treat her with a measure of contempt She comes off in initial description as someone who might be a little soft in the middle.The reader begins to wonder how she managed to get shipped out to a remote asteroid where there s a deadly game being played with the enemy As the reader learnsabout the enemy through the dialogue and stage directions and the ensuing battles the stories of the characters are also quite cleverly played out This seems to me a difficult task using mostly dialogue but M.C.A pulls it off in what might seem like an effortless fashion.The reader soon learnsof Spots as they are drawn into her character with a lot of respect for her The reader soon begins to wonder when Spots unit team members will start to see the light There s a lotto this kick ass woman than meets the eyes.This is all cleverly played out as the reader gets the impression that everything the higher ups do lately has been nothing but trouble and disaster for the unit It s not that difficult to see that they can t recognize that somehow someone has put the right person in the right place.This is not just a story of how Spots grows and hardens up, it s also the story of how the team grows There s a lot to get over and to get through including xenophobia towards their alien adviser And there will be casualties.This story is so rich with character development and intriguing plot that it s enough to keep you riveted to the seat for a while I m sure that it s for the most part my own reading habits that made this such a long read For me every sentence of dialogue counted and had to be digested carefully.Even after a longer than normal time reading I was left hungry forof Spot s, Sam s and Claw s stories I found this to be much better than Starship Troopers.Spots is an excellent, strong and well developed female character.J.L Dobias


  5. Aaron Aaron says:

    Minimalist, surprising, earnest, compassionate, faithful These are words I don t often go for in my fiction Words like Space Marine don t evoke the same kind of excitement as they used to when I was younger and shooting things to death was as cool as it comes.These are the words that describe Spots the Space Marine and I find that it is powerful.If I could ever make a comparison, I would say this is like reading the script to a show like Stargate or Babylon 5 Like those shows the characters a Minimalist, surprising, earnest, compassionate, faithful These are words I don t often go for in my fiction Words like Space Marine don t evoke the same kind of excitement as they used to when I was younger and shooting things to death was as cool as it comes.These are the words that describe Spots the Space Marine and I find that it is powerful.If I could ever make a comparison, I would say this is like reading the script to a show like Stargate or Babylon 5 Like those shows the characters are probably my favorite part of them Unlike those shows this makes me like everything I ve grown cynical about Moments of surprising intimacy and affection are littered among desperate struggles for survival and gun toting jar head jargon Plots I m so familiar with I could see them coming a mile off are offset by, mostly, one character, and that character stands for a lot of things that I, personally, found anathema I found myself reading and waiting for the other shoe to drop, for the dark side to arrive So skillful was the focus of this book that the dark side was there, from the very beginning, but Spots is so very herself, so very into her role as a mother, real or surrogate to her team of marines and even aliens, that I feel like I know what she would say to such sentiments What are you afraid of I was afraid of it being empty like so many things are It s not, if anything this is a minimalistic narrative that is full to bursting with things to say, and really without our main character it could be a standard, Aliens meets x y or z since that s been a marketing gimmick The characters in this feel human though, real, and by doing simple things that have nothing to do with scifi technology or military jargon they become so muchinteresting than many of their contemporaries I feel like this was an excellent choice on the part of the author.To breifly address the controversy around this book Games Workshop wishes it could produce anything like this It s the antithesis of everything their various franchises stand for and if there is a comparison to make it s that they could learn from this work inthan just the workings of copyright law I could tell you about maybe three unique characters in any of their works and little of that would be anything beyond weapon systems and general appearance Everyone in Spots is distinct, we explore them, in and around the hardened military stereotypes they tend to embrace to get the job done I couldn t tell you what Uriel Ventris or Ragnar Blackmane really cares about beyond killing as much of their enemies as possible, but I could tell you about Spots, Claws, Scythe, Fang one and two, Whiskers, Hairball, Wild Dogs, and many others, not just what they are but who they are.This is a book that in a few words can make me emotional It gives me the impressions I need and then lets the characters talk and express themselves, giving the whole picture Little things that stand out in the book are both interesting for commentary purposes and as stylistic choice, such as the choice to asterisk out most of the swear words which I both understand because of our main character but also because swear words are really kind of silly when you look at them that way This is a book that will speak equally to anybody who s ever liked scifi and anybody who s ever had a family and I feel like that is impressive.Read this, seriously I look forward toworks from this author


  6. Alexandra Alexandra says:

    With apologies to the author and editor and publisher, but this title was incredibly off putting I think I got this as part of a bundle of women writing SF there is no way I would ever have bought it, thanks purely to the title I figured it was going to be something about a dog Anyway The title is accurate to the story when you get reading, but I don t think that s a defence So let me assure you this is not a story about a dog trying to be a soldier In fact, the spots refer to a cat wh With apologies to the author and editor and publisher, but this title was incredibly off putting I think I got this as part of a bundle of women writing SF there is no way I would ever have bought it, thanks purely to the title I figured it was going to be something about a dog Anyway The title is accurate to the story when you get reading, but I don t think that s a defence So let me assure you this is not a story about a dog trying to be a soldier In fact, the spots refer to a cat which I found very odd, but whatever The other thing you should know going on is that this is not written like a regular novel It slike a play script it s almost entirely dialogue, with a note for who s speaking but rarely any information about how they re speaking There are italicised comments about the actions happening around some of the dialogue, but it s very sparse compared to most narratives There s even some bits that are described as montages, hammering the film like nature home If this is not going to be your thing, definitely don t go here.This is a military SF novel you also don t want to read it if you don t like Stormship Troopers level killing rate of the alien enemy There is a LOT of killing Mostly the deaths are robot esque, mindless bug ish aliens, but still it got pretty overwhelming So again, may not be everyone s cup of tea The titular Spots has just been transferred to a new outfit to help out with an ongoing war against these alien bugs She s not really physically ready for it, and only just ready mentally The outfit she s joined is desperately low on numbers, and is facing increasing problems from the alien threat that no one had really expected in this area So there s friction with her joining them there s friction from lack of sleep and overwhelming stress there s friction because there s an alien ally on base that not everyone trusts There s a lot of angry people going around One thing I found interesting was that I often lost track of who was male or female, with the exception of Spots, who is a mother The characters go by call signs that have nothing to do with their own names, so every now and then there s some comment about she or he and I was surprised by who it referred to Also, from passing comments, it s clear that the soldiers are from a mixture of races, although I m not sure there was a mixture of nationalities exactly who was sponsoring this military was unclear I enjoyed thisthan I had expected I started reading it because I wanted to either read it or just clear it off my to be read ebook pile While I didn t love the high body count, I was intrigued by the dynamics between many of the characters, and amused by the for the profanity


  7. Jay Phillippi Jay Phillippi says:

    the quality of the writing and the storytelling simply blew me away For the reader looking for action, there is plenty here For the reader hoping for something a little deeper, that desire will be satisfied as well.Hogarth gets the feeling of small unit action and relationships The addition here is the depth of the human element to the story Whether it s Spots deeply held Catholicism or the and feeling of displacement in Fangs, they are touched on at a deeper level than most of the books in the quality of the writing and the storytelling simply blew me away For the reader looking for action, there is plenty here For the reader hoping for something a little deeper, that desire will be satisfied as well.Hogarth gets the feeling of small unit action and relationships The addition here is the depth of the human element to the story Whether it s Spots deeply held Catholicism or the and feeling of displacement in Fangs, they are touched on at a deeper level than most of the books in my experience It also appears in the superb human alien relationship between several of the characters, especially Spots, Claws and the Fiddler.For me, one of the signs of great science fiction writing is the ability to imagine and then realize on the page, an alien race It is simple to create aliens who basically just humans in different skids While the bugs motif here is familiar, Hogarth has created somewhat feels new to me The musical of Samuel Colt s that s the name given to the Fiddler speech is a fascinating concept Emotional intonation and nuance are added to the words through trills and vibratos.The final perfect piece of writing here is the lullaby scene in the second half of the book I won t spoil it for you but if you are not moved by it, I think there may be something wrong with you.Why You Will Like It Great writing, great storytelling, compelling characters Whatcould you want


  8. Mathew Walls Mathew Walls says:

    The screenplay like way it was written made this book seem really long or maybe it actually is long It s hard to tell on Kindle but it felt like a movie only a movie would have been way shorter It could have been a TV show, except that the chapter breaks weren t episode breaks It was weird.I also couldn t help thinking about how their tactics made no sense Why send humans to fight Why not automated or remote operated guns Why not just locate the enemy base and destroy it from space If The screenplay like way it was written made this book seem really long or maybe it actually is long It s hard to tell on Kindle but it felt like a movie only a movie would have been way shorter It could have been a TV show, except that the chapter breaks weren t episode breaks It was weird.I also couldn t help thinking about how their tactics made no sense Why send humans to fight Why not automated or remote operated guns Why not just locate the enemy base and destroy it from space If you ve got interstellar travel then this kind of war just shouldn t happen The only reason to have actual people there is so the story can happen, which is no answer at all.Oh, and the fact that the enemy were the same species as the friendly aliens was delivered like as though it was a twist but it was just obvious And it should have been as obvious to the characters as to the reader.And the forecefields They re extremely limited because portable power sources can only keep them going for short times But why isn t the base surrounded by them And why has it taken so long for anyone to do anything with this mindblowing technology other than use it as riot shields The book is pleasant to read, but the story is just really frustratingly dumb


  9. Bren Bren says:

    This is a fun moving screenplay about a reservist who is called out of retirement to fight giant insects in a space station I enjoyed the graphic novel introduction, the use of food words to describe the color of caucasian skin, the bleeped out swear words, and the ongoing influence the kicking soccer mom has on her squad of marines There is quite a bit of squad interaction that seemed plausible The Fiddler was a great character, too, and there were some excellent experimental weaponry This is a fun moving screenplay about a reservist who is called out of retirement to fight giant insects in a space station I enjoyed the graphic novel introduction, the use of food words to describe the color of caucasian skin, the bleeped out swear words, and the ongoing influence the kicking soccer mom has on her squad of marines There is quite a bit of squad interaction that seemed plausible The Fiddler was a great character, too, and there were some excellent experimental weaponry scenes.Near the end, there was some pretty annoying unauthorized manipulation of our hero s career, and some of the scene descriptions were pretty repetitive, but by large, this was an enjoyable book


  10. Bonnie Bonnie says:

    Not in the mood for the unusual format.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *