The Great Depression A Diary ePUB ã Great Depression

The Great Depression A Diary ☂ [PDF / Epub] ☁ The Great Depression A Diary By Benjamin Roth ✐ – When the stock market crashed in 1929 Benjamin Roth was a young lawyer in Youngstown Ohio After he began to grasp the magnitude of what had happened to American economic life he decided to set down hi When the Depression A Epub Ü stock market crashed in Benjamin Roth was a young lawyer in Youngstown Ohio After he began to grasp the magnitude of what had happened to American economic life he decided to set down his impressions in his diaryThis collection The Great PDF/EPUB ² of those entries reveals another side of the Great Depression—one lived through by ordinary middle class Americans who on a daily basis grappled with a swiftly changing economy coupled with anxiety about the unknown future Roth's depiction of life in time of widespread Great Depression A MOBI · foreclosures a schizophrenic stock market political unrest and mass unemployment seem to speak directly to readers today.

10 thoughts on “The Great Depression A Diary

  1. Jennifer Jennifer says:

    I suspect there are few people who will love this book as much as I did It is essentially a financial affairs diary kept by an attorney living in Youngstown Ohio during the Great Depression As an attorney with a thirsty interest in investment theory and an indecent obsession with all things Great Depression this book was really right up my alleyWhat made this book remarkable was the author's uncanny insight into investment theory Over the course of a single decade the 1930's he singlehandedly developed the same theories it has taken professional financial analysts and economists decades to figure out uite simply he learned from his and his clients' experience of living through the great depression and determined the most advantageous ways to invest through high highs and low lows of the economic cycle I was fascinated to watch his really very simple theories unfold as he observed and evaluated what was happening around him His bits of wisdom included1 People grow their wealth by buying assets when they are CHEAP not soaring 2 Therefore everyone should keep 40 50% of their assets liuid meaning in investment grade bonds or treasuries and the rest of their wealth in high uality stocks for us think index funds like SP 500 index 3 By keeping some assets liuid you put yourself in a position that allows you to buy stocks when they are cheap4 Stocks will always crash When stocks crash bonds soar When stocks crash sell some bonds and buy stocks then hold onto them no matter what5 Likewise when stocks are soaring bonds are usually dirt cheap Therefore when the stock market is setting record highs you should be buying bonds and fewer stocks This way you are always buying assets when they are on sale This is keyThe author repeatedly lamented that in 1929 people who were invested in the stock market were 100% invested in the stock market no one held cash or bonds Therefore when the market crashed they lost EVERYTHING If people had held bondscash during the time of the crash they could have had cash available to buy stocks when they were dirt cheap The author mentioned a few people he spoke with who did exactly this and basically never had to work again But it takes enormous patience levelheadedness and disciplineThe author also struggled with how to time the market How do we know when it is going to turn? When to buy stocks vs bonds? Today we know that this problem can be elegantly solved by sticking to a decided and set asset allocation for instance own your age in bonds If you're 40 years old own 40% bonds etc So say you own 60% stocks and 40% bonds The stock market crashes Stocks go down and bonds go up Now your portfolio is 60% bonds and 40% stocks Excellent Stocks are on sale Time to rebalance your portfolio by selling bonds and buying stocks so that you reach your 60% stock 40% bond allocation again And voila you just bought stocks on sale merely by rebalancing your portfolio We now know that if you do this rebalancing uarterly you will do very well indeed I only wish I could have given the author this missing piece of his puzzle He had literally everything else figured out on his ownA fabulous read

  2. Cailean Cailean says:

    So torn about this book It's such a wonderful concept and it covers ten years of USworld events during the Great Depression Because it was a man's recounting of what he observed and how he felt about economic events there wasn't a lot of meat to the book There wasn't much compelling me to finish it but I did just to see if of a personal narrative developed He points out some very good ideas about how to stay above water during a financial crisis for example always having some liuid assets available so you can use cash to buy whatever you need rather than tying it up in the bank I found especially interesting his observations about WWI and the impending WWII What I didn't like were the distracting editor's notes butting in throughout explaining things that we didn't really need explained Perhaps that's why I felt it was too hard to connect to the author as well All in all worth a read and it only took me a day to read it because of the uniue premise

  3. Chris Chris says:

    I read this book as part of a self imposed homework assignment to learn about financial history The book's suggestion came from reading a smaller work by William Bernstein on personal finance After reading about the dizzying heights of market speculation in Devil Take the Hindmost by Edward Chancellor this book was a sobering reminder of the necessity to live within one's own means and to invest in a diversified portfolio for the long term I think this diary is extremely relevant and strangely comforting for the average American investor Roth's personal accounts highlight many of the same confusions about finance and worries about the future that we have today He writes honestly as he tries to understand the the psychology of investors structural problems of the 1920's boom economy and government's efforts to address the depression He admits that the events of the depression gave him the euivalent of a graduate degree in economics By reading this diary we can reap some of the benefits

  4. Bryce Bryce says:

    Who would have thought that cash was trash during a depression? Well it is if you can't get it out of the bank People sold their passbook savings accounts for 60¢ on the dollar Government bonds were the only useful form of liuid purchasing power A fantastic account

  5. Kalle Nordenstorm Kalle Nordenstorm says:

    Reading historical diaries is important for internalizing how uncertain reality is Read and internalize this It is likely that a new depression or at least 2008 will happen in your lifetime so be prepared for the randomness such events entailReading this book Benjamin Roth uickly earns your respect as a level headed observer None the less time after time he gets things wrong For some time he thought the depression would only last for a year or two Time after time he finds a great investment that he would buy if only he had cash and then its value plummets Everything dropped in value for a year so it looked like a great opportunity for buying but next year they dropped by 60% and so onA paraphrase uote the stock market has made 8 fake starts upwards and then reached new lows Think about it how could anyone know when to buy the super cheap assets If you could just ride out the depression you would make a 400% profit but stuff seemed so random and there was a feasible risk of revolution Some random new perspectives I got from the book Japan attacked China in 1931 likely because they thought the west was occupied by the depression so it was a good time to attack In 1932 he guessed the US might get involved Odd? France seemed unaffected by the depression it even appeared to gain It really looked as if France would be the dominant power in Europe During the depression countries all over the world dropped the gold standard the practice of letting people exchange the national currency for gold which was the ultimate reason you could trust paper money Roth and others initially thought this basically meant nations had basically lost control and their currencies could soon be worthless Cash was a great asset after 1929 By 1932 everything had become 50% cheaper In depressions stupid spending stops Ross says it became poor taste to own a fancy car or having expensive parties People learned to enjoy home family and simple pleasures I like what depression does to a culture I sort of but not really want humanity to live through a permanent depression with Soviet style science projects In 1920 lawyers doctors and others did not save Instead they bought stupid stuff like fancy clothes just like people do today No matter how rich humanity becomes most people can find the stupidity to buy a shirt expensive enough to make him poor A funny fact from this book is that Roth tells you he his parents and grand parents all used to think real estate was the best long term investment That erroneous idea goes back so so farThe most important thing I internalized from reading this book is that the depression just went on and on and on with several false recoveries If you invested 100% of your money when prices had fallen by 60% you would not get your money back for about a decade Unless you sold at the exact right time during a false recovery The entire decade from 1929 to 1939 makes no sense although people can spin persuasive stories about themThis insight which I probably had intellectually but not on a gut level makes me reevaluate my investment plan for a possible crash I want to prosper during a disastrous decade and to come out rich on the other side Some ideas of how to do this Always own three years expenses worth in cash In my case 20 000 dollars In case of 50% drop in prices invest 40% of my money except the 20 000 buffer In case of 90% drop from pre crash level invest an additional 30% The numbers do not add up but that does not matter A depression can be long We have one on record that lasted a decade so a two decade one is plausible Extra investable funds makes sense Invest diversely Stock many currencies including Bitcoin bonds it is ok to buy a home that I am willing to spend a long time in but only if the cash payment of the home would cost less than 40% of my fundsIn years where I guess the market is not overpriced as measured by Price earnings ratios I hold 40% stock 50% conservative assets and cash 5 % weird stuff like Bitcoin that have unlimited potential payoff In the incalculable chance that Bitcoin becomes a widely used currency its value could increase million fold meaning that not owning at least a little bit is stupid Makes sense owning some good lottery tickets But only letting them be less than 10% of your assets

  6. Nick Thorne Nick Thorne says:

    This is mostly a financial diary of the 1930’s by a lawyer It would be worthwhile if Roth actually bought stocks rather than talk about buying them the entire time I realise he had no money to do so though Its has a pessimistic tone which got a little boring sometimes Its worth reading though to help you understand how worthless economic predictions are and shows what it’s like to live through history not look back in hindsight Roth struggles with how to make decisions in uncertainty which I found relates to the current time a global pandemic This was probably my favourite uote “This depression has indelibly impressed on my mind one thing—and that is the value of having on hand sufficient capital to cover emergencies” 90 year old advice still true today

  7. Justus Justus says:

    It is hard to like a book like this The flaws seem to vastly outnumber the good parts but that gives a somewhat skewed perspective I didn't like this book but I'd still recommend others to read the first 100 150 pages or so which is the heart of the depression The remainder of the book is about the years of the New Deal when things are okay though not necessarily great and the Republican author mostly complains about Roosevelt's policies The most interesting parts were about the cavalcade of bank closures and the impacts that had on the communities It is also surprisingly optimistic No doubt a large part of that is because the author had a job even if it didn't always pay well was never foreclosed etc But there's little of the doom gloom I usually associate with the Great DepressionIt is one man's diary with an exclusive focus on financial stuff over the course of a decade It gets repetitive It doesn't start until 1931 a full year and a half after the crash so it misses some of the best part It is also missing 1935 that part of the diary was lost which was when some of the biggest parts of the New Deal went into effect Both of those are very unfortunate omissionsIt is curiously antiseptic There's surprisingly little feeling conveyed of the pain of the depression The author will occasionally mention statistics how 30000 people in his hometown are on government assistance but it never really has much feeling behind it The few emotions that come through often feel a bit selfish about how the professional man ie him is being left behind while laborers and farmers are being helpedIt is uite repetitive Lots of I wish I had some spare cash because I could make a killing by investing now Lots of my business isn't going well It is surprisingly lacking any insight into the author's personal or family situation other than the generic complaints about his business not going well For instance I don't think his wife is mentioned a single time How did they manage to survive all those years if his business was so poor? With all those bank closures did it ever affect any of his cash? Or was he a hoarder?There is no real plot to keep the reader engaged Despite the author saying the depression was like a post graduate course in finance there's no real sense that he learned much or was changed by the experience He started as a staunch conservative Republican and everything he saw is interpreted as confirmation of his previously held views One line that really struck me was his profound belief that the depression should be left to work itself out naturally instead of having any government help at all; an easy position to take when he wasn't one of the 13 million unemployed and never had his house foreclosed It was also interesting to see perennial talking points appearing in the distant past The unshakeable belief in the trust of the government when it comes to government bonds we can only trust the government paired with deep skepticism of government programs Constant cries that massive inflation is right around the corner any day now Constant cries that massive government debt is going to destroy AmericaIt was written as a personal diary so I can hardly fault these short comings It isn't written to be academic to explain why the author believes what he does or to convince you to believe the same things But all of those things also made it hard to keep reading which is why I recommend don't force yourself to be a completionist with this book Read the first 100 pages or so which is the best part Then move on to something else to read

  8. John John says:

    This book is the diary of a man who was a lawyer in Youngstown Ohio during and after the Great Depression The man who wrote it is trying to do two things as he writes First make sense of the depression try and figure out why it happened and whenor if it will end; and two analyze how to invest during a depression of this magnitude Some takeaways1 Lawyers did not do very well during the Great Depression People didn’t have money businesses were cratering real estate wasn’t selling so there was little work for lawyers especially independent lawyers2 Real estate was a very bad investment in the Great Depression unless you had cash to buy at the bottom of the market which few did and calling the bottom was impossible when it actually happened People had no money to make house payments so many fell behind but the cost of getting them removed was great and there was no one else to rent to so people with lots of real estate especially if they were bought as investments ended up owing taxes on the properties with no income which caused very great problems The problems got so bad that owners were razing buildings to reduce their tax burdens3 Mr Roth believes that there was good money to be made at the bottoming out of the stock market because the companies that would survive were great values There were some problems however First the investor needed money and few had money Second the investor needed to be patient with his investment and be willing to ride out declines Third the market zoomed up in 1933 35 then crashed almost to 1932 lows then zoomed up again in 1936 then came the second Depression in 1937 and by 1940 the market was again down near the 1932 lows Investing was very difficult during the Great Depression though there was money to be made4 If there was a formula for success during the Great Depression it was to buy value and this seems to be the long term formula for success at all times buy low and sell high Current investors forget this truth at their peril I very much enjoyed this book

  9. Mahesh Mahesh says:

    This classic book is a precious diary starting in 1931 of a young lawyer Benjamin Roth from Youngstown Ohio His notes provide a vivid picture into the times of the great depression and the events leading into World War II The interesting part is that if you were to erase the dates and just read the content of many of the entries in the diary you will be shocked to find out many of the same themes you encounter today Even surprising is Benjamin Roth's lament of people not learning from the past mistakes of the depression of 1893 or 1873 From political polarization to real estate speculation to Wall Street's excesses to overbuilding you will read through some common themes that have been a landmark of human folly throughout the modern era The diary also provides great insight into the tough daily life in America during the depression years Whats heartening to see is that Benjamin Roth despite being a staunch Republican and a strong believer of market forces went canvassing regularly in his town for parts of Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal for the sake of the country This book is a must read

  10. Christine Christine says:

    I found this a fascinating read mostly There are entries that perhaps would have been better left out and they bordered on tedious I find books about the Depression tend to fall into 2 categories the black and white image of depressed poverty or the glories of the New Deal This book is the life of one man Just a guy who ponders what the heck is going on I never tire of seeing the ways history repeats itself and Roth does a fine job of pointing that out

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *